Tuesday, December 31, 2019

The Destructors - 1014 Words

John Copenhaver English 102 Fiction Essay, Thesis and Outline Instructor Freshwater Thesis Statement: Both Greene’s â€Å"The Destructors† and Lawrence’s â€Å"The Rocking-Horse Winner†, particularly the climax of each story, illustrate a powerful preoccupation with the ruining of lives because of a desire to control the material world. Outline: I. Introduction--thesis statement as well as introductory material regarding the two texts to be referenced. II. The Destructors--a discussion of Greene’s story a. major plot points from the story b. T.’s impulse to control the material elements of the house c. the obsession with materialism and its effect on Mr. Thomas’s life III. The†¦show more content†¦Young Paul decides to take to gambling, specifically on horse races. In a bit of magical realism, Paul is able to accurately predict the winner of any horse race so long as he rides his own wooden rocking-horse while searching for the answer. But no matter how much that Paul earned through gambling, it was never enough. As the Derby drew near, â€Å"the boy grew more and more tense. He hardly heard what was spoken to him, he was very frail, and his eyes were really uncanny† (Lawrence 306). In the end, Paul made over 70,000 pounds on that race alone, but the stress of his divination costs him his life (Lawrence 308). Because Paul believed that more and more money was necessary for his family to survive, he continued to push himself harder and harder to win more and more. The stress of this path, however, was ultimately self-destructive and cost Paul his life. No matter how hard he tried to control the material wealth of the family, his und erlying belief that there must always be more money would destroy his very life for the sum of more than 70,000 pounds. In both Greene’s â€Å"The Destructors† and Lawrence’s â€Å"The Rocking-Horse Winner† we see a pervasive, and perverse, need to control the material world in both the characters of T. and Paul. The former attempted to enact such control by destroying what he found beautiful, while Paul was driven to win more and more money. The end result of both actions, though, was remarkably similar: the material control soughtShow MoreRelatedA Critical Analysis of The Rocking-Horse Winner and The Destructors1240 Words   |  5 PagesA Critical Analysis of The Rocking-Horse Winner by D.H. Lawrence and The Destructors by Graham Greene In both stories, The Rocking-Horse Winner by D.H. Lawrence and The Destructors by Graham Greene we see the common theme of wanting to be envied by others because of what we have or can do. The need to do better, have prestige and more power than anyone else is a very common human conflict that is dealt with on all levels of humanity. The emotional environment that man growsRead MoreThe Basement Room, By Graham Greene1091 Words   |  5 Pagesrelation to the good of other people. Renowned author Graham Greene explores this theme from what some people believe to be a Christian perspective in his many of his works. Although two of Graham Greene’s short stories, â€Å"The Basement Room† and â€Å"The Destructors,† are neither clearly redemptive or biblical, it is very possible that the stories are written from a Christian worldview because of their parallels to the nature and consequences of sin, and Greene’s criticism of selfish human behavior. â€Å"The BasementRead MoreThe Lottery vs the Destructors Essay examples1046 Words   |  5 PagesThesis In Shirley Jackson’s, â€Å"The Lottery†, and Graham Greene’s â€Å"The Destructors†, the author creates a story filled with symbolism, irony, grim reality, and a ritualized tradition that masks evil, which ultimately showcases how people blindly follow tradition. Outline I. Introduction II. Setting B. Time Period III. Plot A. What messages are seen inRead MoreThe Destructors Essay747 Words   |  3 PagesCharacters Trevor (T) : A silent, decided, and seemingly frustrated teenager . He speaks nothing more than needed and yes or no forms most of his answers. He becomes a member of the gang because he wants to take revenge of a society in which his parents have come down. His father, formerly an architect, is working as a clerk ; and his mother considers herself better than the neighbors. This leaves T with nothing better to do than join the local gang. In the destruction of Old MiserysRead MoreThe Decline Of British Bees2223 Words   |  9 Pagesbees, causing widespread declines. There are a variety of afflictions that are affecting insect life in the UK with the honey bee most notably affected. Varroa Destructors, a parasitic mite are wiping out bee colonies worldwide, in the past hundred years or so it has become the most serious pest of bees across the world. Varroa destructor developed from a pest of an Asian honeybee which appear to be mostly unaffected by the mite. When the European honeybee pic ked up the mite however it had disastrousRead MoreAnalysis on The Destructors by Graham Greene 820 Words   |  4 PagesThe Destructors written by Graham Greene as a third person view. The story set in London nine years after the end of World War II. People survived from The Blitz. The Blitz was Nazi Germanys sustained aerial bombing campaign against Britain in World War Two.(The Blitz) Everything was in chaos, people lost their home, slept in the underground station and lost their hope for the future. The story is about a group of teenage boys who formed a gang and call themselves as the Wormsley CommonRead MoreEssay on A Comparison of The Destructors and Lord of the Flies2333 Words   |  10 PagesA Comparison of The Destructors and Lord of the Flies      Ã‚  Ã‚  Ã‚   In Graham Greenes The Destructors, the author presents the Wormsley Common car-park gang, a group of adolescent delinquents who commit petty crimes for fun. William Golding, in his novel Lord of the Flies, presents a slightly younger group of boys who are wrecked on an uninhabited island and develop a primitive society that eventually collapses and gives way to despotic savagery. Although these two casesRead More The Signficance of Violence in Graham Greenes The Destructors793 Words   |  4 PagesThe Signficance of Violence in Graham Greenes The Destructors In serious fiction, no act of violence exists for its own sake. Graham Green, in his short story â€Å"The Destructors,† reveals certain intangible needs met through one central act of violence. One need we all have as humans is the need to be creative, to express ourselves, to use our imagination. All little boys use their imaginations, which is based on what they see in their environment, whether that be television or their ownRead MoreAnalysis Of The Book The Destructors By Graham Greene945 Words   |  4 Pageshustles readers to the end is the reason why they picked a story that is more commercial fiction or literary fiction. Commercial fiction drives readers away from the real world, while literary fiction deepens the reader’s awareness of life. â€Å"The Destructors† by Graham Greene is a short story that stresses the tension between social classes following the aftermath of World War II. This realistic fiction grasps historical context to reveal the purpose of the destruction of a house. The Wormsley CommonRead MoreAnalysis Of The Book The Destructors By Graham Greene954 Words   |  4 PagesPicasso remarked during the later parts of his life. Even Picasso’s genius creative mind knew the potential that destruction has in terms of life; an untapped force of creation and desire awaiting to be fulfilled. In the legendary short story â€Å"The Destructors† by Graham Greene, protagonist Trevor is an intelligent fifteen year old boy who joins a children’s gang in the wake of the Second World War Seemingly set back in life by the horror of the war, Trevor cannot find himself without a certain pain festering

Monday, December 23, 2019

America Is A Nation of Immigrants Essay - 2105 Words

For over 300 years, various ethnic, cultural, and social groups have come to this country to seek economic opportunity, reunite with family members, and find a place where they can be free from political and religious persecution. I suspect a majority of American-born citizens believe that immigration is a bad thing in this country that is harmful. Those particular Americans believe that this country is being infested by foreigners who cannot even speak our own language. However, if one were to look at the truth behind these fallacies, he/she would see that immigration is beneficial to our country and should not be abandoned. Instead, it should be increased. Approximately 800,000 immigrants enter the United States each year. Of†¦show more content†¦Although many Americans think of immigration as illegal border hopping, there are people who actually do come here legally to improve their lifestyle or to be reunited with loved ones. Many people who disapprove of immigration base their opinions on arguments that are purely fictitious. One such argument against immigration is that immigrants take away American jobs and are a drain on the U.S. economy. However, the only competition with immigrants is the skilled immigrants versus the skilled natives, and the unskilled immigrants versus the unskilled natives. Therefore, the person with the most skills deserves the job. If that person is an immigrant, then so be it. Obviously stated, the person who works the hardest and has the most knowledge gets the reward. Immigrants only hurt those who are less qualified. Another problem that comes up when talking about immigrants taking away jobs is that immigrants will work for less, so they are hired more often than are the natives who are seeking employment. Of course immigrants will work for a lower wage; they want to succeed in this country and in order to live a decent life, they need an income, and they best and m ost legal way to do such a thing is to work. If they cannot find employment elsewhere, they will settle for being paid lower wages. Instead of putting the blame on immigrants, people should look to the cause of the problem: the employers. It is not the immigrant’sShow MoreRelatedAmerica Is A Nation Of Immigrants1561 Words   |  7 PagesUnited States of America is a nation of immigrants. Therefore, our American journey and our achievements merely not be possible without the generations of immigrants who have come to our shores from every corner of the earth. And It is helpful to take a moment to mirror on the important aids by the generations of immigrants who have helped us build our economy, and made America the economic engine of the world. Because some of these Immigrants with there being here in U.S, the economy will be shakingRead MoreAmerica as a Nation of Immigrants Essay1787 Words   |  8 PagesAmerica as a Nation of Immigrants America has, is, and will always be a nation of immigrants: the great melting pot. In the years that have passed since Emma Lazarus poem was inscribed on the Statue of Liberty the golden door Americans have seen times when the door was open wide and times when it was close shut to most immigrants (Sure 4). Many people look at the present immigration problems as a purely modern dilemma. The truth is America has always struggled with the issue of immigrationRead MoreAmerica Is A Nation Full Of Immigrants1840 Words   |  8 PagesAmerica is generally a nation full of immigrants. The biggest beckon of immigrants was witnessed in the nineteenth century (Maestro and Ryan 11).The immigrants mainly consist of refugees from problematic areas all over the word. They have contributed a great deal to the rich structure of life of the American population. Many immigrants come to America in search of greener pastures. It is called â€Å"the land of the free.† The immigrants carry great e xpectations with them as they come to America but areRead MoreAmerica Is A Nation That Created By Settlers And Immigrants948 Words   |  4 Pagescountry for numerous reasons. America is a nation that was created by settlers and immigrants; it boasts an inherently diverse assemblage of citizens, unlike many other countries in the world. It’s a country that was built by people with a distinct set of values that honor an individual’s â€Å"God-given† rights; a set of values that further shaped how the world came to understand and view humanity. Admittedly, what I’ve come to learn about America feels fairly distant, as America has grown and changed throughoutRead MoreA Nation Of Immigrants And The United States Of America2299 Words   |  10 PagesA NATION OF IMMIGRANTS The Ways that Immigration has Shaped and Benefited the United States of America Scott Williams US History Plato Unit Activity Give me your tired, your poor, Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free... -- Emma Lazarus (from the poem The New Colossus) These words by Emma Lazarus, inscribed on a plaque on the Statue of Liberty, strike a chord of yearning for freedom in the minds of suffering yet hopeful people, and invoke a picture of the United States meeting the immigrantRead MoreHow Can America Become A Better Immigrant Nation?1245 Words   |  5 PagesHow Can America Become a Better Immigrant Nation Again? It has become evident to many that the American economy is declining in recent years. Journalists are pointing out that one of the reasons why it got weaker is due to a failed immigration system and outdated policies towards illegal immigrants. For instance, Fareed Zakaria from Time magazine says, although America was once considered an example to many other immigrant nations, it is now falling behind some of them in terms of immigration-relatedRead MoreThe Land Of Opportunity : Immigrants1509 Words   |  7 PagesThe Land of Opportunity Immigrants created America, a nation that has embraced immigration. Throughout the years, America developed its â€Å"American Dream† concept, which states that anyone can succeed in the United States as long as that person works hard and does gives up. That concept, hope or dream attracts thousands of individuals, many of which leave their native countries with their hearth full of hope and the illusion of reaching and living the â€Å"American Dream.† However, the wonderful dreamRead MoreImmigration : An Influential Aspect Of American History1172 Words   |  5 Pagesbeginnings of the nation in the seventeenth century to the present day, millions of people, from a variety of different and distinct nations and cultures, made the great journey to the United States to pursue greater economic and social opportunities. Immigration has been an influential aspect of American history. These immigrants have enhanced and contributed greatly to the fabric and the story of Amer ica. They have brought with them diversity and aspects of their cultures that made America the great meltingRead MoreImmigration, The Land Of Opportunity For People1478 Words   |  6 Pagesimmigration has shaped America into who she is today. July 4, 1776, was the day immigrants first stepped onto North American soil and claimed the land as theirs. The impact of migration on a country this big can’t be ignored, especially because the people coming to live in America are usually from Third World countries and are looking for employment and to be shown a better way a life. Like anything else, there are both huge pros and cons to Third World immigration. Once, America was known as the landRead MoreThe Official Definition Of Illegal Is â€Å"Contrary To Or Forbidden1517 Words   |  7 Pagesis â€Å"contrary to or forbidden by law†. The definition of an Immigrant is â€Å"an individual who comes to live permanently in a foreign country†. Therefore Illegal Immig rants are foreigners who enter another country, the United States of America, without a Visa. They cross the border by avoiding inspection and overstay the allotted period of time allowed as a visitor, tourist, or businessperson. There are 12 million illegal immigrants in America today. How is the possible if it is illegal? And more importantly

Sunday, December 15, 2019

My Essay Free Essays

Tymaine McBee March 21, 2013 Personal Statement Essay My name is Tymaine McBee and I am currently a student/trainee at OBT (Opportunities for a Better Tomorrow). The reasons why I have enrolled in OBT are to obtain my GED, get enrolled on a good college, and to get a good job. The main reason why I’m here is because high school didn’t really work out for me. We will write a custom essay sample on My Essay or any similar topic only for you Order Now I was always getting into trouble and everything else you can imagine. I was just a problem child but I hope I can get through OBT. I have faith that I can. The first reason why I chose to enroll in OBT is to get my GED. I feel that high school really wasn’t for me. Why you ask? Well, when I was in high school, I used to get in lots of trouble like fighting, hanging around with the wrong crowd, and getting locked up. I feel that OBT will help me obtain my GED because the staff here no only help you with school work they help you get ready for the business world as well. I think these skills will help me survive because in the real world you need business skills and school smarts to survive. My second reason why I enrolled into OBT is to get a job. The reason why I want a job is to help my grandmother out around the house, with bills and rent. I’m also looking to get a job so I can support myself like buying stuff that I need. Another reason why I’m looking to get a job because this will be the first job I ever had. I had previous chances to work for summer youth but I messed those chances up by getting locked up. But the main and most important reason why I’m hoping to get a job is so I can take care of my grandmother because she is very sick. The third reason why I go enrolled in OBT was to get into a good college. I’ve always wanted to go to college but I wasn’t the brightest kid in the world. One of the colleges I would like to go to is Hunter College. I would like to go to college to study computer networking, law, and nursing. The reason why I want to study computer networking is because I love computers and I want to learn how to network one. The reason why I want to study in law is because I’m a good speaker and I fight for what’s right also I know how to hold a good argument. The reason why I want to study in nursing is because I want to give back to the community like I want to help old people get better when they are sick. In conclusion, I enrolled in OBT to get my GED, get into a good college, and to get a good job. I just hope that I can make it through this program without any slip-ups or anything. I really have faith that I can make it through these 23 weeks and get my GED and do something productive with my life instead of doing wrong. I’m glad that I’m a student/trainee at OBT its going to open new doors and opportunities for me in the future. How to cite My Essay, Essay examples My Essay Free Essays Tymaine McBee March 21, 2013 Personal Statement Essay My name is Tymaine McBee and I am currently a student/trainee at OBT (Opportunities for a Better Tomorrow). The reasons why I have enrolled in OBT are to obtain my GED, get enrolled on a good college, and to get a good job. The main reason why I’m here is because high school didn’t really work out for me. We will write a custom essay sample on My Essay or any similar topic only for you Order Now I was always getting into trouble and everything else you can imagine. I was just a problem child but I hope I can get through OBT. I have faith that I can. The first reason why I chose to enroll in OBT is to get my GED. I feel that high school really wasn’t for me. Why you ask? Well, when I was in high school, I used to get in lots of trouble like fighting, hanging around with the wrong crowd, and getting locked up. I feel that OBT will help me obtain my GED because the staff here no only help you with school work they help you get ready for the business world as well. I think these skills will help me survive because in the real world you need business skills and school smarts to survive. My second reason why I enrolled into OBT is to get a job. The reason why I want a job is to help my grandmother out around the house, with bills and rent. I’m also looking to get a job so I can support myself like buying stuff that I need. Another reason why I’m looking to get a job because this will be the first job I ever had. I had previous chances to work for summer youth but I messed those chances up by getting locked up. But the main and most important reason why I’m hoping to get a job is so I can take care of my grandmother because she is very sick. The third reason why I go enrolled in OBT was to get into a good college. I’ve always wanted to go to college but I wasn’t the brightest kid in the world. One of the colleges I would like to go to is Hunter College. I would like to go to college to study computer networking, law, and nursing. The reason why I want to study computer networking is because I love computers and I want to learn how to network one. The reason why I want to study in law is because I’m a good speaker and I fight for what’s right also I know how to hold a good argument. The reason why I want to study in nursing is because I want to give back to the community like I want to help old people get better when they are sick. In conclusion, I enrolled in OBT to get my GED, get into a good college, and to get a good job. I just hope that I can make it through this program without any slip-ups or anything. I really have faith that I can make it through these 23 weeks and get my GED and do something productive with my life instead of doing wrong. I’m glad that I’m a student/trainee at OBT its going to open new doors and opportunities for me in the future. How to cite My Essay, Essays

Saturday, December 7, 2019

Introduction to Legal Skills

Questions: What are the two most important concepts you have encountered on W101? Explain why they have had a direct effect on your thinking. How will you change your own way of working, either in your studies or in your employment, as a result of your studies on W101? Answers: Introduction: Studying is concerned with much more than the knowledge regarding the subject and that is the reason the skills are developed during the learning stage. Defining few of the constructs included in the scope has been significantly more challenging than traditional constructs. The importance of subject specified skills have been known and learned during this study and the same have been explained through this report. The main skills that had endeavoured my skills have been explained in the report. Their effect on my learning and future impact on working or studies had been also explained. The obstacles that were part of my learning are also part of the report. The manner in which my thinking and working style has been reformed after the studies has also been included in the report. Effect Of The Two Main Concepts Learned During W101 On Thinking Cognitive Skills It can be said as intellectual skills which are concerned with the identification, description, application and description. Analysis and synthesis of study are also included in it. These skills are the major skills of our brain that are used by it for thinking, learning, reasoning and remembering (Bondi and et.al., 2016). These skills enable one to construe, explain and apply legal principals and authorities in a coherent manner. It assists one in identifying the factors of legal argument and analysing the interpretations. It can also be said as reflective thinking which is focused on ascertaining what to believe or do. According to Braye and Preston-Shoot, 2016 the one who has inbuilt the enhanced cognitive skills in itself can interpret the law appropriately on a word to word basis and can ascertain the correct governing rule relating to it. It plays an important role in processing new information. The probability of desirable result is increased with cognitive skills rather than outcomes of non-critical thinkers (Cooper, 2016). Due to this reason it had not only directly influenced my thinking but also changed the manner of taking a decision. The result that I observed after changing the method of decision taking was surprising and positive. As previously I take a decision without critical analysis but now I take a decision after analysing the factor relevant to circumstances; the outcomes which come are pretended or desirable most of the time. In the case of subject law, these skills play a major role as if one is having enhanced cognitive skills one can easily interpret the rules and regulation in the form they are present. I recognised its importance at learning stage of this study. The result after learning this skill on my work was the reason that it directly affected my thinking. Case studies, laws and regulations are interpreted in an appropriate manner after being acknowledged with the skills (Samantha Love, 2013). To recommend conclusion of a case or to reach a conclusion, it is very necessary that one should interpret the law and the case in appropriate manner (Furniss, 2013). Law and regulation can be interpreted in an appropriate manner only when one is having cognitive skills. The advantage that I received through this skill is now I am able to test the validity of propositions inappropriate manner. Practical Professional Skills The learning during this study also enhanced practical and professional skills assisted me not only in academic study but in another context also, such as workplace and even in taking decisions of daily life. The identification and application of primary and secondary sources of law become easy and is done in an appropriate manner if one is inbuilt with practical and professional skills (Gruzd and et.al, 2016). The other advantages one can achieve after developing these skills are: Relevant matter can be extracted from a case study or statute Time can be managed effectively. Our own development is reflected as a learner. Things are understood in the form they are present and the possibility of confusions is reduced. Presentation of report or assignment with these skills represents your own development. The drastic change in my own working after practising on these skills had directly impacted on my thinking. Things were easy for me than before they were, improvement in the manner of presentation was also done. As this practical skills effect on every decision, whether it is related to professional or daily life (Niedwiecki, 2012). The estimations regarding a case law were appropriately taken now and not without any base, the manner which was followed by me previously. The regular practice of professional and practical skills not only develops other skills but also improve the ability to take the correct decision. It plays a major role in law subject; as things are to be critically analysed here and even small information can have major importance (Put and et.al., 2016). Having enhanced practical and professional skill is important in subject law because the practical application of law and rules is majorly present in this subject. Impact on studies or employment of the two concepts: In law, definition tends to be both general and broad and to make it useful for test development it is necessary that they should be specified (Seabrooke, 2014). Therefore, they could be a conception of sharing that definition in assessments and case laws. It is only possible with enhanced cognitive skills because with them only we are able to interpret the law in an appropriate manner and apply it. It is not an easy job to understand the language of the law as its application includes many parts such as the rule of domain-specific or domain-general and many others are also present (Surden, 2014). Developing cognitive skills in myself not only improved my ability to understand the laws and regulations but also enhanced my writing skills. These skills assisted me in presenting assessments in an appropriate manner which is used by me during my studies in solving case laws. It has changed the manner of my working too, which will help me in my future employment. I am able to critically analyse the case and to abstract the important data from it and to ascertain the law under which it will be governed. I am practising it in my current projects to improve these skills in a better way so that I could gain more advantage from it in my future. The role of the legal profession in the legal system was analysed by me during this study while developing practical and professional skills. The skills that should be present in student of law or a new lawyer (Key skills for successful legal professionals, 2016) ; which I learned during the study are: Identification of ethical issues in practice and resolving them. To learn about the circumstances in which ethical concerns regarding compliance of trust with accounting obligation should arise. Acknowledging and meeting legal duties relating to connection with dealing in others property. Appropriate measures should be taken to avoid a rise of conflict in future. Presenting professional behaviour in all the dealings with clients as well as authorities. The lesson of professionalism was learned by me during the study which is not only improving my image now but will also help in creating goodwill in future. I learned about the importance of ethical behaviour during this study and to have patience while working in a group. The importance of pro bono contributions to legal practice was observed by me and even I learned the method of using it. The enhancement in professional skill which was developed during the study, I am practising these skills in my daily routine to make more improvement in it. The information regarding accounting for trust money was also obtained during the study. The procedure of identifying the legal characteristics in a case law and analysing the coherent conflictions with governing laws was explained to me that is assisting me in my other projects and will help me during my employment also. These skills will help me during my employment period as till that time I will gain enough experience to behave professionally and also to interpret the law in an appropriate manner. Conclusion: It can be concluded from the above case study that cognitive skills and practical professional play a major role in the field of law. As analysed above that cognitive skills are necessary for correct interpretation of law and regulations and on the other hand, practical and professional skills play a major role in ethical issues. The lessons that I have learned during the study will assist me in future also. The development of skill will help me in completing other projects and also during my employment period. The enhancement in practical and professional skill had improved the manner of behaving with authorities which will help me in future for making a good reputation. References: Books Journal: Bondi, L. And et.al ( 2016). Towards professional wisdom: Practical deliberation in the people professions. Routledge. Braye, S. and Preston-Shoot, M. (2016). Practising social work law. Palgrave Macmillan. Cooper, J.M. (2016). Smarter Law Learning: Using Cognitive Science to Maximize Law Learning. Capital University Law Review, 44. Furniss, T. (2013). The multi professional handbook of child sexual abuse: Integrated management, therapy, and legal intervention. Routledge. Gruzd, M.V.and et.al (2016). Influence of professionalism and competence in public administration. Niedwiecki, A. (2012). Teaching for Lifelong Learning: Improving the Metacognitive Skills of Law Students Through More Effective Formative Assessment Techniques. Cap. UL Rev., 40, p.149. Put, K .and et.al. (2016). Using web-based training to enhance perceptual-cognitive skills in complex dynamic offside events. Journal of sports sciences, 34(2), Pp.181-189. Seabrooke, L. (2014). Epistemic arbitrage: Transnational professional knowledge in action. Journal of Professions and Organization. 1(1), Pp.49-64. Surden, H.(2014). Machine learning and law. Wash. L. Rev., 89, p.87. Online Key skills for successful legal professionals. (2016). [Online]. Available through https://www.lawcareers.net/Information/Key-skills-for-successful-legal-professionals. [Accessed on 31st August 2016]. Samantha Love. 9 Essential Skills for Aspiring Lawyers. (2013). [Online]. Available through https://www.oxford-royale.co.uk/articles/professional-development-aspiring-lawyers.html. [Accessed on 31st August 2016].